Monday, 4 July 2016

Membership Report - Specifier: June 2016

As we continue to promote CSC, the need for value in the construction industry is greater than ever. Since our last report in May, the Vancouver Chapter membership stands at 154.

For More Information on Membership:
Please contact Mario Maggio
Tel: 778-986-6058
E: mario_maggio@usalum.com

Sunday, 3 July 2016

CSC Construction Tour - Specifer: June 2016

The annual CSC Construction tour in May was a big success!

We met for lunch at the Dublin Crossings Restaurant and then on to explore the Marine Gateway Project. This is a new concept of combining retail and residential in one location. The entire project is built on a geothermal plant which allows buyers to predict and then lock into energy prices for the next 30 years. In cooperation with BC Hydro, tomorrow’s energy bill will be the same as today. The entire project sold out in record time.

Several of the restaurant sites were selected after all residential sites were sold and residents were able to participate in requesting which restaurants to add. Sky trains arrive and depart to the city regularly so the need for a vehicle is drastically reduced. The concept is to be energy responsible and have a better quality of life. Less glass and more thermally efficient panels may lead the way to better building practices in BC.

Thank you to our hosts from Perkins & Will Architecture: Ryan Bragg, Development Lead and Joshua Rudd, Intermediate Designer.

Download the issue for photos.

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Saturday, 2 July 2016

Sufficiency of Notice: What Types of Details Need to be Included in a Notice of Dispute? - Specifier: June 2016

By Jared Epp, Robertson Stromberg Barristers and Solicitors

Building contracts, like CCDC contracts, frequently require parties who disagree over things like extras to submit particulars of their dispute to an engineer for determination. The findings of the engineer can then be challenged by either party in arbitration. The detail that must be included in these dispute notes was recently discussed by the Ontario Court of Appeal in Ross-Clair v. Canada (Attorney-General).

The Facts

In this case, a general contractor (“Ross-Clair”) was hired by the federal government to build management offices at the Millhaven Institution, which is a maximum security prison located in Bath, Ontario. The parties’ contract set out detailed requirements in terms of how Ross-Clair was to submit claims for extras:
35.3 When the contractor has given a notice referred to in GC 35.2, the contractor shall give the Engineer a written claim for extra expense or loss or damage within thirty (30) days of the date that a Final Certificate of Completion referred to in GC 44.1 is issued and not afterwards.
35.4 A written claim referred to in GC 35.3 shall contain a sufficient description of the facts and circumstances of the occurrence that is the subject of the claim to enable the Engineer to determine whether or not the claim is justified and the contractor shall supply such further and other information for that purpose as the Engineer requires from time to time.
If either the Owner or Ross-Clair disagreed with the findings of the Engineer, they could elect to have the issue determined through binding arbitration. However, arbitration was only available if and after the Engineer made a finding.

A number of issues arose during construction, most of which centered on Ross-Clair’s inability to meet the scheduled completion date, which was January 24, 2009. A number of letters were exchanged between the parties on this issue. These letters later formed the foundation for Ross-Clair’s claim for extras and provide context to the dispute.
  1. December 5, 2008 Ross-Clair informs the Engineer that an extension is needed to complete due to delays caused by the owner and that Ross-Clair has incurred additional costs of $1,437,976. Ross-Clair indicates it will provide a breakdown of these costs in the future. 
  2. December 16, 2008 the Engineer advises Ross-Clair that it needs more information before it can process a claim for extras. 
  3. February 27, 2009 the Owner reminds Ross-Clair that it has failed to complete the project on time. 
  4. March 2, 2009 Ross-Clair informs the Owner that Ross-Clair is entitled to an extension due to owner caused delay. RossClair also attaches a document listing the sub-contractors it owes money to for the project. These costs total $1,437,976. 
  5. April and May 2009 both the Owner and Engineer request that Ross-Clair provide additional documentation in support of its extras claim. 
  6. October 6, 2009 the Owner grants Ross-Clair an extension to complete without prejudice to the right to object to the extra costs Ross-Clair is claiming. 
  7. March 31, 2011 Ross-Clair claims additional costs of $766,700. 
  8. April 2, 2011 the Owner advises Ross-Clair that its letters did not contain enough information for the Owner to be able to process the claim for extras. 
  9. February 10, 2012 the Engineer certifies the project as being complete. 
  10. May 28, 2013 Ross-Clair provides the Owner with a detailed report breaking down its claim for extras.

Ultimately, the Owner refused to pay Ross-Clair’s claim for extras. However, the Owner also instructed the Engineer not to make a finding in response to Ross-Clair’s May 2013 report, thereby depriving Ross-Clair of the ability to seek arbitration. Ross-Clair then sought a court order requiring the Engineer to rule on its claim for extras.

The Results

In considering this issue, the Court discussed whether or not the letters prepared by Ross-Clair gave the Engineer sufficient information about the claim for extras. At the outset, the Court noted that the detailed report submitted by Ross-Clair in May 2013 could not be considered because it was delivered, contrary to GC 35.3, more than 30 days after the Final Certificate of Completion was issued. This meant that the details of Ross-Clair’s claim were limited to what it set out in its 2008 and 2009 letters.

In considering whether or not these letters had enough detail to satisfy the notice requirements in the parties’ contract, the Court stressed the fact that the contract needed to be interpreted as a whole. This meant that the provisions in the contract, which regulated how extra work would be priced (ex. costs of labour, materials, costs to hire sub-trades, over-head mark-up costs) needed to be outlined and detailed in the claim for extras, as without it the Engineer would not have the information needed to make a meaningful decision.

The court was also very concerned with the fact that Ross-Clair had not responded to the Owner or the Engineer’s request for more information until May 30, 2013, which was more than 12 months after the project was completed. Given these circumstances, Ross-Clair was not allowed to advance its claim for extras.

Conclusion

The decision reached in Ross-Clair is significant for a number of reasons including:

  1. It reiterates the importance of ensuring that the strict notice provisions, in terms of dispute notes, be followed. Had RossClair provided its detailed report for extras within 30 days of completion, the court might have required the Engineer to rule on whether or not these extra costs were legitimate; 
  2. It confirms that “one-liner, emailed” notices of dispute are often not good enough. Rather, contractors must, and can be expected to, take care to alert the owner as to when extra costs have been incurred as well as to provide the owner with meaningful information as to what these extra costs consist of. For example, if a contract states that extras will be paid on a cost-plus basis, it may not be enough for a contractor to say it is been delayed and it has suffered a certain amount of damages. Rather, detailed breakdowns of labour and material costs, as well as a specific explanation as to why these costs were incurred, should be provided in the initial dispute note; and 
  3. It highlights the importance, particularly for an owner, of having a diligent engineer on site. Had the Engineer not told Ross-Clair that it needed more details to process its claim, the court may have had more sympathy for Ross-Clair’s plight.

Ultimately, Ross-Clair serves as a reminder to contractors that they need to take care in completing notices of dispute, and also reminds engineers and project managers that they can demand information that they need to fairly evaluate requests for additional payment both in terms of whether or not the extras are legitimate and what the cost of the extras might be.

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Friday, 1 July 2016

Words from the Chair - Specifier: June 2016

June is here and the CSC chapter is preparing for our annual SpecGolf tournament coming up on July 14th. The new time and venue is in response to the tough time the chapter has getting everyone out in September. We’re hoping that there aren’t too many people away on vacation. If you like the date or have any feedback, please let me know. We are currently still trying to gather feedback for the program report, so if you or someone you know wants to get involved and present, please bring your ideas forward. We’ve also been notified that Simon Wong will the recipient of the CSC Vancouver Chapter Bursary award this year. Every year the chapter awards $750 to a BCIT student, the awards ceremony took place on June 22nd, 2016

For those that didn’t get to make it out to Halifax for CSC National Conference this year, you missed out, the Halifax chapter sure knows how to plan a great event. I’ve never seen so much lobster stacked on plates as there was at the fun night. Our Director (Kim Tompkins) was the best dressed pirate and also got inducted in the College of Fellows. This is only awarded to those have made outstanding contributions to CSC (job well done Kim, you deserve it!).

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Saturday, 21 May 2016

Membership Report - Specifier: April 2016

As we continue to promote CSC, the need for value in the construction industry is greater than ever. Since our last report in March, the Vancouver Chapter has picked up some momentum of interest and has increased by ten new members which bring our membership to 172.

Please help us to WELCOME 10 new members:

NEW to the CSC VANCOUVER CHAPTER:

Mr. Laurence Matzek
Director of RoofStar Guarantee Program
RCABC Guarantee Corp.

Mr. Neil Hastie
Regional Manager,
Pacific National Concrete Accessories

Mr. Michael Venne
Commercial Consultant
Beaulieu Canada

Mr. Arthur Tseng
Architect
Bing Thom Architects

Mr. Jeffery Leech
President
Canadian Stone Industries

Mr. Daryl Muz
Architectural Specifications Mgr– AB & BC
PPG Architectural Coatings

Mr. Roland Jung
Associate
ABBARCH Architecture Inc.

Ms. Jaclyn Louie
Architect & Design Representative
Bay Resource Group

Ms. Megan Chalmers
Architect AIBC, AIA Intl.
ZGF Cotter

Mr. David W. Rock, CCCA
Construction Manager
EllisDon Corporation

For More Information on Membership:
Please contact Mario Maggio
Tel: 778-986-6058
E: mario_maggio@usalum.com

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Thursday, 19 May 2016

Be Careful What You Wish For: When a Breach of 'Contract A' May not be Worth Contesting - Specifier: April 2016

The Alberta Court of Queen’s Bench has recently issued yet another Contract A/Contract B decision, but this one has an interesting twist to it. In Elan Construction Limited v. South Fish Creek Recreational Association (2015 ABQB 330), the Court confirmed, if not strengthened, what we already knew about the bidding process – that the Owner must evaluate all bids fairly, consistently and in accordance with the stated evaluation criteria and the reasonable expectations of bidders, and that exclusion clauses will not save the Owner when they have clearly departed from these obligations. However, despite successfully showing that the Owner breached these obligations for Contract A, the Contractor in this case learned that sometimes a win is not always a win.

What happened?

In 2010, South Fish Creek Recreational Association (“Fish Creek”), a collective group of non-profit sports and community associations, decided to move forward with a project to add 2 additional ice surfaces and a multi-purpose room to an existing recreation facility. The budget was approximately $19 million, and the Consultant (Quinn Young Architects) prepared an Invitation to Bid and Instructions to Bidders for the project. Only pre-qualified bidders were invited to bid, which included, among others, Elan Construction Limited (“Elan”) and Chandos Construction Ltd. (“Chandos”).

To alleviate Fish Creek’s concerns about roping itself into a project using a contractor with a shoddy reputation, the Consultant outlined four criteria in the Instructions that would form the basis of the bid evaluation: price, completion date, experience and references. Each category was assigned a specific number of points for evaluation purposes.

Ultimately, the project was awarded to Chandos, and Elan voiced its protest, claiming that the project was awarded based on criteria not disclosed in this evaluation matrix. As a result, Fish Creek found themselves heading to the courthouse for an alleged breach of Contract A.

The Court agreed with Elan, finding that Fish Creek did, in fact, significantly depart from the evaluation criteria outlined in the Instructions, specifically:

On completion date:

  • While the Invitation bolded August 1, 2011 as the desired substantial completion date, the Consultant internally split the points in this section between substantial completion date and date for completion of deficiencies. Then, he created a complex formula for awarding these points. He first excluded several bidders from the completion date analysis (one for being an ‘outlier’ from the rest of the dates, and others for unexplained reasons), and used the remaining dates to create an average completion date, which was used as a baseline for awarding points to the remaining bidders. The same analysis was applied to the points for the deficiencies completion date. None of this, the Court explained, was communicated to the potential bidders, and the Court held that the combination of all these actions actually worked against Elan, who reasonably assumed that the highest points would be awarded to those who could commit or come closest to the August 1 date.
On experience:
  • In awarding points, Fish Creek placed considerable weight specifically on arena building and LEED experience, though neither of these were referenced in the bid documents. 
  • Following submission of the bids, Fish Creek decided to conduct interviews with Elan and Chandos, though this requirement was not disclosed in the bid documents either. Adding further insult to injury, Elan was informed that the interview must take place on August 18, despite the fact that Elan’s site superintendent and project manager were unable to attend on those dates. 
  • And, just prior to the interview, Chandos substituted the site superintendent shown in its bid with a ‘ringer’ in the arena building department, and as anticipated, his references and qualifications proved quite charming to Fish Creek during the interview process. Given that amendments to the bids were only allowed prior to the bid closing date, the Court found this substitution to be a significant breach that could not be passed off as an ‘informality’ waived by the exclusion clauses in the bid documents.
Naturally, Fish Creek argued that their exclusion and privilege clauses in the bid documents were wide enough to provide a full defence to any breaches claimed by Elan, particularly because they required Elan to “waive any right to contest any legal proceedings regarding the decision of the Owner to award points under the criteria noted below.” However, the Court disagreed, and re-affirmed that such clauses do not detract from the Owner’s obligation to treat bidders fairly and to disclose all criteria that will be used to evaluate the bids.

As a result, the Court confirmed that Fish Creek did, in fact, breach Contract A. And, the surrounding facts clearly supported Elan’s claim that, but for Fish Creek’s breaches, Elan would have been awarded the contract for the project.

Before you pop the champagne…

Let’s hope that Elan read the Court’s decision from back to front, as it would have saved them from the inevitable letdown in the damages analysis undertaken by the Court. Anyone who has spent $100 at the fair throwing baseballs at milk jugs, only to be presented with a one-eyed stuffed bear as the prize, will have a taste of Elan’s bitter disappointment in this department.

Elan presented the Court with a ‘lost profit’ damage calculation using their historical figures, which supported a 5% profit margin on similar projects. Their lost profit on the project, they argued, was approximately $700,000.

But the Court reminded them that a damage award must place them in the same position as if the breach had not occurred. And what position would that be? Well: 
  • One of Elan’s listed subcontractors had actually underestimated the scope of work required, and on the evidence presented, the Court found that Elan would have been forced to absorb at least some of the cost associated with this error. 
  • Both Elan and Chandos had listed the same masonry and paving subcontractors in their bids. Chandos testified that it incurred additional cost on the project to replace both of these subcontractors (the former because they were deemed ‘too high risk’ to contract with, and the latter because they fell into receivership). The Court was persuaded that Elan could not have escaped these additional costs either. 
  • Chandos suffered severe losses due to unexpected weather conditions, as 2010 just happened to be an unusually cold and early winter in Calgary. Based on the evidence presented, the Court found that Elan would also have incurred these inevitable costs.
  • Finally, there were major delays on the project due to various unanticipated design issues, all of which proved costly for Chandos. Once again, the Court found no reason why Elan would have escaped similar costs of this nature. 
All things considered, Chandos provided evidence showing that it had actually suffered a substantial loss on the project, and the Court found that Elan, too, would have incurred a substantial loss as opposed to a profit had they been awarded the contract instead. So, while Elan celebrated its successful breach of Contract A claim, the celebration quickly turned sour when the Court awarded them nominal damages of $1,000. 

What can we learn from this?

Consultants should keep this case in mind when preparing bid documents and evaluating submitted bids. Specifying rigid evaluation measurements may prove dangerous, as the Courts will scrutinize these criteria closely to ensure the ‘integrity of the bidding process’ is upheld at all times. 

And while its unsettling to believe that you were treated unfairly during a bidding process, Contractors should put careful thought into the hypothetical outcome of the project had it been rightfully awarded to them. In other words, be careful what you wish for – you just might get it.

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Tuesday, 17 May 2016

Words from the Chair - Specifier: April 2016

As I sit in my hotel room here in Drummondville, QC, I can’t help but miss the warmer weather to be had back home. I see snow piles remaining from a couple days ago, while at home we see tulips everywhere.

We are a little more than 1 month away from a departure flight to Halifax and I must say this is a trip I’m looking forward to. I’ve never been to Halifax, but I’ve heard this Chapter really knows how to throw a party. The Vancouver Chapter are looking forward to conference this year because we get a chance to host the Hospitality Suite on Thursday May 26th. Let’s show the National crowd what to expect for next year in Kelowna.

Please join us next month (May 12th) for our annual site tour taking place at the Marine Gateway project. This mixed use project is located on the new skytrain line to make for easy access. We will have lunch at the Dublin Crossing Pub (466 Marine Dr, Vancouver). After lunch Ryan Bragg (Lead Architect) and Joshua Rudd will take us on a tour of the project while explaining the project history and process.

On another note, registration is now available on our website for the annual Spec Golf tournament. We have changed date and venue this year. The tournament will be held on July 14th at Fort Langley Golf Course. Please register soon; this is a great chance to bring a customer out for a day of golf and network amongst your peers during the dinner and prizes night.

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Monday, 16 May 2016

Spec Golf 2016

Thursday, July 14, 2016

Fort Langley Golf Club

Construction Specifications Canada is a multi-disciplinary, non-profit association dedicated to the improvement of communication, contract documentation and technical information in the construction industry. Many of our members are independent business people covering most aspects of the consulting sector of the construction industry. Our local membership includes Architects, Engineers, Specification Writers, Consulting and Design Professionals and (product) Technical Representatives.

The CSC Vancouver Chapter is pleased to offer you an opportunity to meet these people by participating in our Spec Golf 2016 Annual Golf Tournament as a Hole Sponsor. Where else can you get this kind of exposure for such a reasonable cost AND Play Golf! This year’s tournament is being held on Thursday, July 14th at Fort Langley Golf Club at 9782 McKinnon Crescent, Langley. It will be a Shotgun Start (1pm) with a Texas Scramble format so that we can all have fun and start/finish at the same time.

As a Spec Golf 2016 Premium Sponsor, you will receive the following benefits:

  • Signage at a tee-box 
  • Green fees, golf cart, snack and beverage at the turn and a banquet meal for one golfer 
  • A business card ad in our Chapter Newsletter (a $225.00 value) 
  • A special newsletter edition that will recognize all of our Hole Sponsors 
  • Recognition at the tournament banquet


Premium Sponsorship - $430.00 - EARLY BIRD RATE $410 till June 3, 2016
Includes all above. Please ensure we have a current business card for the ad!

Basic Sponsorship - $330.00 - EARLY BIRD RATE $310 till June 3, 2016
Includes Hole Signage, Golf and Dinner for one golfer . NO BUSINESS CARD AD

Additional Golf & Dinner - $170.00 - EARLY BIRD RATE $145 till June 3, 2016

Total includes GST

REGISTER ONLINE
Online at Karelo by VISA, MasterCard, or Interac Online.

REGISTER BY FAX
The registration form available at vancouver.csc-dcc.ca. Payment can be made at the door by cash, cheque, or VISA only.

Monday, 9 May 2016

Site Tour - Marine Gateway Development Building Tour

Thursday, May 12, 2016

Presented by Ryan Bragg and Joshua Rudd, Perkins+Will Canada Architects

Marine Gateway development in Vancouver, an 80,000 square meter mixed-use project located on the city's new rapid transit line. Marine Gateway sets a standard for sustainable development associated with mass transit and includes a district energy system, an extensive water resource management plan, high-performance building envelope and shading strategies while incorporating two transit stations.

The building is basically complete with occupancy already awarded. After lunch we will have a brief introduction to the project history and process by Ryan, followed by a group tour through Highstreet. From there we can break into two groups to tour the office (Ryan will start at the lobby, and Joshua will start at Level 18).

Ryan Bragg is the development lead. Previous city-scale projects include the transformation of a complete city block into the Princess Street Campus for Red River College in Winnipeg and the regeneration of Rotherham City Centre in the United Kingdom.

Joshua Rudd is an intermediate designer and recently attained his Certified Passive House Designer designation.

NOTE: PPE is not necessary on this tour.

LOCATION
Meet in Dublin Crossing Pub, 466 SW Marine Drive, Vancouver (in the Marine Gateway Development).

AGENDA
11:30 am - 12:30 pm - Luncheon (selected sandwiches)
12:15 pm - 12:30 pm - Chapter Business and Guest Speaker Introductory Presentation
12:30 pm - 1:30 pm - Marine Gateway Building Tour

COST
$38.00 plus GST for pre-registered CSC members / Association Executive Directors
$48.00 plus GST for non-members
Limited to first 40 registrants.

PARKING
Various locations.

SKYTRAIN
Exit Skytrain at Marine Drive station

REGISTER ONLINE
Online at Karelo by VISA, MasterCard, or Interac Online.

REGISTER BY FAX
The registration form is available at vancouver.csc-dcc.ca. Payment can be made at the door by cash, cheque, or VISA only.

PRE-REGISTRATION
Pre-registration ends at 2:00 pm on the Wednesday before the meeting.
Limited to first 40 registrants.

CSC Vancouver is a Registered AIBC Provider.
AIBC Members will receive 1 core LU (Learning Unit) for attending this event.

RCI has approved this meeting for 1 RCI Continuing Education Hour (CEH).
Members to request attendance certificate.

Friday, 8 April 2016

Education Report - Specifier: March 2016

As a representative of CSC (in continuing our relationship with BCIT), I once again attended the Industry Student Career Mixer for the Architectural and Building Technology Students at BCIT last Wednesday evening, February 3rd, promoting the benefits of being a member of our Vancouver Chapter and the possible enrollment in the courses offered in continuing education for both writing and reading specifications associated with the Construction Industry. At that time, I also confirmed with BCIT’s main ABT instructor, Antonio Sanjuan, that, once again, I will be representing CSC while lecturing to his class on the Importance of Specifications for his 2nd Year course curriculum this Spring.

Respectfully submitted,
Glenn Chatten

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Thursday, 7 April 2016

Membership Report - Specifier: March 2016

As we continue to promote CSC, the need for value in the construction industry is greater than ever. During the month of January, the Vancouver Chapter has increased by five new members which bring membership to 165.

Please help us to WELCOME four new members and one rejoining member:

Mr. Jordan Gervais 
Architectural & Technical Representative
IKO Industries

Marie de Montigny-Simoneau A.T., LEED AP ID+C, C.Tech.
Senior Architectural Technologist
DIALOG

Mr. Glen Stokes
Partner
Carscadden Stokes McDonald Architects Inc.

Mr. Gerhard Unger 
Contract Administrator
DIALOG

For More Information on Membership:

Please contact Mario Maggio
Tel: 778-986-6058
E: mario_maggio@usalum.com

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Tuesday, 5 April 2016

Specs Overrule Drawings... REALLY - Specifier: March 2016

By Keith Robinson, FCSC, RSW, CCS, LEED AP

As specifiers, we are called into many uncomfortable meetings with a request to clarify exactly what was intended by the written words that we create as a part of the Project Manual... and are often left with the uncomfortable feeling that the only reason we are at these meetings is to be “the person” to blame where a satisfactory conclusion has not otherwise come to fruition. This is not an unusual feeling for anyone that has been assembling or administering construction specifications for any amount of time, but this particular interpretation is used way too often and without sufficient thought about how this hierarchy exists. Hence the ~ (tilde) and ¿ (upside down question mark) in the title indicating the sarcastic bent of the word really in the title line and in other instances in this article.

There is no doubt about the “Order or Priority of Documents” arising in the event of conflict within the Contract Documents, which is defined in our standard CCDC forms of contract. The issue with this statement is the difference of our “general understanding of conflict” versus the “legal interpretation of conflict”.

Since I am not a lawyer; the discussion presented is merely an opinion. The word “conflict” as used in the contractual instance is the legal interpretation where there is a breach of contract. Essentially someone is about to be sued, and the conflict refers to the process of resolving the dispute. The word “conflict” as used by the general (non-lawyer-ish) understanding is any disconnect between the specifications and the drawings, a disagreement between facts and an individual’s interpretation of the documents, or any perceived disagreement (or argument) during the administration of the project that doesn’t actually form a breach of contract (but has the potential if not resolved amicably).

It is important to accept that there needs to be a line in the sand; a point of decision making, to enable fair and equal interpretation of the documents. The specification is being used as the tool for this demarcation based on the accepted order of priority. The question and sarcastic inference at the start of this column comes about when the specification is inconsistent with the graphic representation (drawings) and where we need to move the discussion to a more controversial line of discussion. What happens when the drawings are correct and we do not want the spec to rule? What about the unintentional disconnects that occur when the drawing notes are too specific – should the drawing notes be considered a specification? If drawing notes are specifications – then what happens to the book (specifications)?

Our standard CCDC forms of contract offer us backup to support of the graphic representation and accompanying notes by stating “Contract Documents are complementary, what is required by one is required by all”. We humbly march forward feeling self confident that we are justified in switching the ruling documentation (in the eyes of the constructor) from the specification to the drawing, and now we are steering towards a conflict in the true legal sense... a potential for breach of contract.

In arriving at a more reasoned approach to interpreting the contract documents, we need to understand what a specification is and what a drawing is. Strange as those notions are given that we are an association of specification writers. It is the start of a historical tour of events leading to the interpretation of the working-drawings and specifications that we have today.

Some of the earliest interpretations of the word “drawings” are referenced in the late 1700’s and early 1800’s (1) as “the workingdrawings contain the graphical information placed on sheets of vellum or other reproduction” with the intent that everything else on the drawing sheet are considered words. Those words had specific context leading to our predecessors (2) and to our current interpretation of the order of priority of documents. The current interpretation was derived from the following concerns (quoted in the language of the time) in the late 1800’s:

  • Of the exactness requisite in the practical profession of architecture, and how far it is influenced by the correctness of specifications and working-drawings
  • Of the disputes and expenses which arise from badly drawn specifications
  • Of the trouble and vexation which an architect occasions to himself by a badly drawn specification; and on the propriety of general clauses in specifications
  • Of marginal references in specifications and contracts, their convenience, and their tendency to insure the correct performance of the work; and of the care with which specifications should be copied into contracts
  • Of the advantages which would result, if copies of the working-drawings and specifications for all works, were deposited somewhere for the public and private reference
  • Of the evil and depressing influence which bad building has upon architecture
  • Of the influence which contracting for the erection of buildings has upon architecture 
  • Of the present state of architectural mechanical knowledge 
  • Of the question, “Have we improved in our Practical Building through specifications?”

Seems we are challenged with similar concerns in today’s construction environment and causes one to ponder from this historical information, “Why haven’t we seen progress in our documentation in the last 125 to 150 years to address these concerns?” Fortunately, both of these publications laid out the principles of interpretation that are used by CCDC, and which we are familiar with in today’s common usage of the order of precedence of the documents:

  • Words add clarity and content to graphical representations and working-drawings.
  • Words are understood in their general and popular usage. 
  • Words commonly accepted by trade usage are understood as standard or technical terms and have precedence over general or popular usage.
  • Specific and defined terms take precedence over standard or technical terms. 
  • Typed words take precedence over printed words (think of old style drawing methods where words were hand printed). 
  • Handwritten words take precedence over typed or printed words (handwriting is considered as reflecting the immediate thoughts selected by the parties themselves to express their joint understanding of the meaning of words).

The disconnect in today’s interpretation is that the word “drawing” is taken to be the “sheet of paper” that we bind together as a set of working-drawings rather than the graphical content on those sheets as was the original interpretation. When words are added to the graphical content, they become an integral component of the specification information that adds clarity to the drawings. Words printed on the drawing must match the words written into the specification...this disconnect arises by our failure to recognize that drawing notes are specifications.

This becomes a bigger issue given our need to add more detail to the drawing notes than is necessary to convey clarity or content, especially considering the weight provided to the specification under contract. The more detailed the drawing notes are, the greater the likelihood of creating discrepancies and potential for disputes as a result of those discrepancies.

So what is the solution to this dilemma? Communication, another word that everyone thinks they perform effectively, but which so often fails in the process of delivering the message. The ultimate irony is that we are failing to communicate because of our need to provide overly descriptive notes on our working drawings and failing to forward a message, speak with or otherwise send smoke signals to the person responsible for the written words that actually take precedence, and ultimately provides the communication to the person that delivers the finished project.

Do we assume that the specification isn’t as good as the contract gives it credit? Do we overcompensate by adding descriptive text and sequential context to drawing notes that ignores the flow of communication that is supposed to occur between the drawings and the specification? This becomes a self fulfilling conclusion... the specification is no good, because no one thought to communicate the project requirements into the written document... so the contractual significance of the specification is lost to the big recycle bin in the back rooms, basements and back alleys of so many buildings.

Sounds like an action plan for BIM concepts and software – a solution finally sounds like a discussion for a different column.

(1)  Handbook of Specifications, Practical Guide to the Architect, Engineer, Surveyor and Builder in drawing up Specifications and Contracts for Works and Constructions; T. L. Donaldson Ph.D., published by Atchley and Co., published in 1860. Also viewable online, University of Michigan HathiTrust Digital Library

(2)  Specifications for Practical Architecture; Frederick Rogers, Architect, published by Crosby Lockwood and Co., published in 1886. Also viewable online, Internet Archive 

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Monday, 4 April 2016

Luncheon - Fireproofing 101: Back to the Basics

Thursday, April 7, 2016


Presented by Ron van Frankfoort Director of Sales Commercial Fireproofing - Northeast US & Canada Carboline Company / AD Fire Protection

This session will discuss the basics of fireproofing in the design and construction of building projects today. It will address questions on why and when it is required, what the testing requirements and certification processes are, and provide a review of ULC /ITS classifications. A brief explanation of the different types of cementitious and intumescent types of fireproofing materials that are available in the market will be carried out as well as a discussion on where each type of product should be specified and used (ie. advantages / disadvantages). This presentation will also include a review of the different types of finish levels for intumescent fireproofing and photos of different types of applications.

Learning objectives will include the following:
  • Why Fireproofing is required
  • What are the testing requirements and certification process for fireproofing materials and the ULC / ITS classifications
  • What are the different types of cementitious and intumescent types of fireproofing materials that are available in the market.
  • Where each type of product should be specified and used (advantages / disadvantages)
Ron van Frankfoort has been involved in the fire protection industry for approximately 28 years. For the first 12 years of his career he was a consultant with Leber-Rubes Inc., a Fire Protection Consulting Engineering company based in Toronto. He’s since been employed by AD Fire Protection Systems, a manufacturer of fireproofing and firestopping materials for the past 16 years and the Director of Sales for Canada and the US in the past 5 years.

LOCATION
Sandman Hotel, 180 West Georgia Street, Vancouver 
Enter Moxie’s Classic Grill escalator entrance. The ballroom is located straight through the restaurant at the back of Moxie’s.

AGENDA
11:30 am - 12:30 pm - Luncheon (full course self-serve buffet style)
12:15 pm - 12:30 pm - Chapter Business
12:30 pm - 1:30 pm - Guest Speaker Presentation

COST
$38.00 plus GST for pre-registered CSC members / Association Executive Directors
$48.00 plus GST for non-members

PARKING
Sandman Hotel Parking: Enter off Cambie Street, pass the Sandman Hotel Breezeway, underground parking to the left, press buzzer to access parkade and take elevator to restaurant level. Cost is $1.25 per 15 minutes.
Easy Park: Across the street on the corner of Georgia and Cambie Streets. Cost is $1.50 per 30 minutes.

SKYTRAIN
Exit at Stadium-Chinatown Station. Walk 2 minutes.

REGISTER ONLINE
Online at Karelo by VISA, MasterCard, or Interac Online.

REGISTER BY FAX
The registration form is available at vancouver.csc-dcc.ca. Payment can be made at the door by cash, cheque, or VISA only.

PRE-REGISTRATION
Pre-registration ends at 2:00 pm on the Wednesday before the meeting.

WALK-INS WELCOME
Missed the deadline? Did not pre-register? You may still attend at $50.40 per person, space permitting, BUT please call 604-868-8406 beforehand.  If you pre-register and do not attend, we may invoice you for the cost of the meeting. If you have special dietary (meal) requirements, please notify us at least 24 hours before the event.

CSC Vancouver is a Registered AIBC Provider.
AIBC Members will receive 1 core LU (Learning Unit) for attending this event.

RCI has approved this meeting for 1 RCI Continuing Education Hour (CEH).
Members to request attendance certificate.

Words from the Chair - Specifier: March 2016

In February David Valk of Jenkins Marzban Logan spoke about “The Consequences of Failing to Uphold Worker Safety Regulations”. This is always an interesting topic that directly or indirectly affects many people within the industry on every project. It’s always interesting to hear the take on past cases that were the result of safety to ensure that we learn from past mistakes to ensure safer times ahead. We all have families we like to get home to see at the end of the day, so let’s speak out when we see unsafe acts on sites. In addition CSC National is hosted a Winter Workshop in Vancouver for Construction Contract Administration (CCA) March 7-11, 2016. This gave people the option of completing the course in 5 days. This course was held at the Pacific Gateway Hotel in Richmond. If you or someone you know is interested in any of these courses or the variety of online courses offered, please let us know.

We’re a little over 2 months away from Conference in Halifax. Hopefully everyone has a chance to see this event. Having gone for a number of years now, I can say it’s fun. The Vancouver Chapter will host the Hospitality Suite on Thursday May 26th. We’d really like to have a great presence to prepare for Conference in Kelowna in 2017. Hope to see you there!

James Kelly CTR
Chapter Chair CSC – Vancouver Chapter

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Wednesday, 9 March 2016

Luncheon - Demystifying Acoustics

Thursday, March 10, 2016

Presented by Andre Rioux AcousticTECH/Soprema Soundproofing

This presentation outlines basic acoustic principles and definitions, specifically the transfer of impact and airborne sounds in multi-story buildings. Efficient means of acoustic insulation will be discussed using multiple case studies of recent floor-ceiling assemblies. This presentation benefits industry professionals such as architects, designers, acoustic engineers, builders, and general contractors interested and/or concerned with acoustic insulation of multi-story buildings.

Participants will learn the following:

  1. Basic Acoustic Principles and Definitions 
  2. Impact and Airborne sounds in multi-story buildings 
  3. Means of soundproofing buildings 
  4. The do’s and don’ts of acoustic design
Since the creation of AcoustiTECH in 2000, Andre has been traveling all over Canada, the United States and the UAE to make presentations to groups of architects, project managers, general contractors, flooring contractors and more.

Andre’s experience combined with the expertise of his team has resulted in AcoustiTECH being the number one reference in the field of acoustics for new and existing buildings. After over 15 years, Andre continues to enjoy meeting with professionals and collaborating in the success of their projects.

LOCATION
Sandman Hotel, 180 West Georgia Street, Vancouver 
Enter Moxie’s Classic Grill escalator entrance. The ballroom is located straight through the restaurant at the back of Moxie’s.

AGENDA
11:30 am - 12:30 pm - Luncheon (full course self-serve buffet style)
12:15 pm - 12:30 pm - Chapter Business
12:30 pm - 1:30 pm - Guest Speaker Presentation

COST
$38.00 plus GST for pre-registered CSC members / Association Executive Directors
$48.00 plus GST for non-members

PARKING
Sandman Hotel Parking: Enter off Cambie Street, pass the Sandman Hotel Breezeway, underground parking to the left, press buzzer to access parkade and take elevator to restaurant level. Cost is $1.25 per 15 minutes.
Easy Park: Across the street on the corner of Georgia and Cambie Streets. Cost is $1.50 per 30 minutes.

SKYTRAIN
Exit at Stadium-Chinatown Station. Walk 2 minutes.

REGISTER ONLINE
Online at Karelo by VISA, MasterCard, or Interac Online.

REGISTER BY FAX
The registration form is available at vancouver.csc-dcc.ca. Payment can be made at the door by cash, cheque, or VISA only.

PRE-REGISTRATION
Pre-registration ends at 2:00 pm on the Wednesday before the meeting.

WALK-INS WELCOME
Missed the deadline? Did not pre-register? You may still attend at $50.40 per person, space permitting, BUT please call 604-868-8406 beforehand.  If you pre-register and do not attend, we may invoice you for the cost of the meeting. If you have special dietary (meal) requirements, please notify us at least 24 hours before the event.

CSC Vancouver is a Registered AIBC Provider.
AIBC Members will receive 1 core LU (Learning Unit) for attending this event.

RCI has approved this meeting for 1 RCI Continuing Education Hour (CEH).
Members to request attendance certificate.

Tuesday, 9 February 2016

Luncheon - Risking it All: The Consequences of Failing to Uphold Worker Safety Regulations

Thursday, February 11, 2016

Presented by David Volk, Lawyer, Jenkins Marzban Logan LLP

Through a review of some recent high-profile workplace accidents which resulted in catastrophic injuries or fatalities, this session will focus on the risks associated with responsible parties failing to uphold work safety regulations. The session will address issues like who is responsible for upholding such regulations, what the consequences can be for failing to do so, and the contemporary approach of government regulators such as WorkSafeBC to these incidents. This session will be relevant to anyone involved in the construction process, including persons responsible for the design or planning of construction methods

At the end of this presentation, participants will be able to:

  1. Current understanding of Workplace Safety Regulations in British Columbia
  2. Understand the responsibility and consequences of failing to uphold these regulations
  3. Approach and response of government regulators such as WorkSafeBC

David’s practice is almost exclusively focused on construction matters since joining Jenkins Marzban LLP in 2015. David acts for all types of parties in the construction industry, ranging from owners and general contractors to material suppliers. David represents his clients in all aspects of the dispute resolution process, including mediation, arbitration, litigation and settlement negotiations. David was called to the British Columbia bar in 2011.

LOCATION
Sandman Hotel, 180 West Georgia Street, Vancouver 
Enter Moxie’s Classic Grill escalator entrance. The ballroom is located straight through the restaurant at the back of Moxie’s.

AGENDA
11:30 am - 12:30 pm - Luncheon (full course self-serve buffet style)
12:15 pm - 12:30 pm - Chapter Business
12:30 pm - 1:30 pm - Guest Speaker Presentation

COST
$38.00 plus GST for pre-registered CSC members / Association Executive Directors
$48.00 plus GST for non-members

PARKING
Sandman Hotel Parking: Enter off Cambie Street, pass the Sandman Hotel Breezeway, underground parking to the left, press buzzer to access parkade and take elevator to restaurant level. Cost is $1.25 per 15 minutes.
Easy Park: Across the street on the corner of Georgia and Cambie Streets. Cost is $1.50 per 30 minutes.

SKYTRAIN
Exit at Stadium-Chinatown Station. Walk 2 minutes.

REGISTER ONLINE
Online at Karelo by VISA, MasterCard, or Interac Online.

REGISTER BY FAX
The registration form is available at vancouver.csc-dcc.ca. Payment can be made at the door by cash, cheque, or VISA only.

PRE-REGISTRATION
Pre-registration ends at 2:00 pm on the Wednesday before the meeting.

WALK-INS WELCOME
Missed the deadline? Did not pre-register? You may still attend at $50.40 per person, space permitting, BUT please call 604-868-8406 beforehand.  If you pre-register and do not attend, we may invoice you for the cost of the meeting. If you have special dietary (meal) requirements, please notify us at least 24 hours before the event.

CSC Vancouver is a Registered AIBC Provider.
AIBC Members will receive 1 core LU (Learning Unit) for attending this event.

RCI has approved this meeting for 1 RCI Continuing Education Hour (CEH).
Members to request attendance certificate.

Monday, 4 January 2016

Luncheon - Green Roof Design for Stormwater Management

Thursday, January 14, 2016

Presented by Dr. Karen Liu, Research & Development, Bonar Xeroflor

Green roofs have been consistently experiencing double-digit growth over the past decade. A major driving force has been stormwater management. This luncheon meeting will discuss how to design green roofs specifically for stormwater management and examine various municipal policies and programs and their pros and cons in promoting green roof installation for stormwater management.

The stormwater management potential of a vegetative roof depends on its water storage capacity as well as the rainfall pattern and climate zone where it is located. Water detention and retention characteristics of the individual components will be looked at and a review of how these components interact within a green roof system to manage stormwater runoff.

The sessions will also demonstrate how innovative water retention materials can maximize water storage while keeping the weight low. A concept of water-retention-to-weight ratio will be introduced to compare different green roof components to assist designers to make the proper choices.

A case study: The Broadway Tech Centre will be used to illustrate how these tools can be used in designing green roofs for stormwater management.

At the end of this presentation, participants will be able to:

  1. Understand the principal mechanisms behind how green roof manages stormwater 
  2. Design a green roof to meet prescriptive- or objective-based stormwater policies 
  3. Design green roofs for stormwater management using technical principles and data 
  4. Specify green roof components/systems based on water-retention-to-weight ratio

Dr. Karen Liu is the product manager for Bonar Xeroflor. She has been conducting green roof research since 2000 when she was a research officer at the National Research Council (NRC) in Ottawa, and led the green roof research team at the British Colombia Institute of Technology (BCIT) in Vancouver. Karen established the first North American field facility dedicated to green roof research and conducted several field studies across Canada to study the climate sensitivity of the technology. She now focuses her work on product development at Bonar Xeroflor.

LOCATION
Sandman Hotel, 180 West Georgia Street, Vancouver 
Enter Moxie’s Classic Grill escalator entrance. The ballroom is located straight through the restaurant at the back of Moxie’s.

AGENDA
11:30 am - 12:30 pm - Luncheon (full course self-serve buffet style)
12:15 pm - 12:30 pm - Chapter Business
12:30 pm - 1:30 pm - Guest Speaker Presentation

COST
$38.00 plus GST for pre-registered CSC members / Association Executive Directors
$48.00 plus GST for non-members

PARKING
Sandman Hotel Parking: Enter off Cambie Street, pass the Sandman Hotel Breezeway, underground parking to the left, press buzzer to access parkade and take elevator to restaurant level. Cost is $1.25 per 15 minutes.
Easy Park: Across the street on the corner of Georgia and Cambie Streets. Cost is $1.50 per 30 minutes.

SKYTRAIN
Exit at Stadium-Chinatown Station. Walk 2 minutes.

REGISTER ONLINE
Online at Karelo by VISA, MasterCard, or Interac Online.

REGISTER BY FAX
The registration form is available at vancouver.csc-dcc.ca. Payment can be made at the door by cash, cheque, or VISA only.

PRE-REGISTRATION
Pre-registration ends at 2:00 pm on the Wednesday before the meeting.

WALK-INS WELCOME
Missed the deadline? Did not pre-register? You may still attend at $50.40 per person, space permitting, BUT please call 604-868-8406 beforehand.  If you pre-register and do not attend, we may invoice you for the cost of the meeting. If you have special dietary (meal) requirements, please notify us at least 24 hours before the event.

CSC Vancouver is a Registered AIBC Provider.
AIBC Members will receive 1 core LU (Learning Unit) for attending this event.

RCI has approved this meeting for 1 RCI Continuing Education Hour (CEH).
Members to request attendance certificate.

Wednesday, 30 December 2015

Trade Show Update - Specifier: December 2015

November 18th, 2015 was our fifth annual Trade Show at the Vancouver Convention Centre. First off, many thanks to all the exhibitors who participated this year, the volunteers the day of the event, the architects and members of the design community who walked the show floor and finally the Trade Show Committee responsible for countless hours of work throughout the year to make it all happen. The day featured three separate guest speakers; Murray Frank of Constructive Home Solutions, Brian Palmquist & Marsha Gentile of Ledcor, and Dirk Laudan of Borden Ladner Gervais LLP . In addition, we added wine draws throughout the day with three separate winners walking away with 10-12 bottles of wine. At the end of the show, an I-Pad was raffled off to eligible participants who visited and collected ten signatures from presenting exhibitors. Congratulations to this year’s winner, Glenn Chatten. In addition, Michael Apostolides from B + H Architects was the winner of the set of Vancouver Canucks hockey tickets. Special thanks to this year’s committee members: Todd Gerrard of Enercorp, Brian Maher of Dryvit, Ken Emsley of Soprema, Vince Smith of Cloverdale Paint, Jeff Dye of Tec Agencies, Ryan Foster of Roxul, and Calvin Lewis of Flextile . The team is now actively looking for new suggestions on how to make this event better, so if you would like to add your input into what happens in the future, please reach out to someone from the Executive and put your comments forward.


Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Tuesday, 29 December 2015

Spray Foam 101 - Specifier: December 2015

By: Scott Ruffett, CTR, LEED Green Assoc., ICYNENE

Over the last several years, provincial energy codes have changed to reflect the demand for more energy efficient buildings. The use of modern, cost effective insulation materials such spray applied foam insulation (SPF) can assist the building designer meet these new code requirements. Providing energy efficient buildings creates an opportunity to reduce energy consumption, lower our utility costs, improve occupant comfort and indoor air quality, and reduce pollution and greenhouse gases.

Choosing the right SPF product can be a challenge. Designers should carefully consider the project requirements to ensure a smooth and successful completion. Whether designing to meet minimum code requirements for thermal performance (R-Value) in a wall, roof or floor, or in a more complex commercial airbarrier system application, there is an SPF product that meet your project’s needs.

The two main SPF options for building designers are classified as light-density and medium-density. Both product types are excellent insulators providing superior air-sealing qualities and can be used in commercial, residential, new construction or renovation projects.

R-values for light-density products range between R-3.5 to R-4.1 per inch. These products can be considered air-barriers and require a vapour barrier in most applications. Light-density foams expand up to 100 times the liquid volume and are known for filling voids and cracks within the cavity making them an ideal choice for building reclamation and renovation projects or in details where there is a large and complex amount of framing that would difficult to insulate with traditional materials.

Medium-density foams have higher thermal performance, are air barriers as well as vapour barriers (VB in applications greater than 50mm). R-values of medium-density foams are higher than light density foams, ranging from 5.11 per inch to over 6 per inch. Medium-density foams are robust and can be used as a component of the building envelope. Furthermore, medium-density spray foams provide a water resistant barrier in cavity wall details. Other common applications are stud wall cavities, interior side of roof applications, below grade interior or exterior applications or under pour in place concrete floor slabs.

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.

Monday, 28 December 2015

Words from the Chair - Specifier: December 2015

December is finally upon us, the Christmas party rush is here. This month Fiona Famulak is presenting at our December luncheon. Fiona will be presenting her insight on the outlook for 2016 and beyond. The industry keeps humming along and seems busier now than at this time last year. VRCA has been meeting with their membership over the last year with a goal towards improving the quality of construction documentation. CSC continues to strive towards the same objective and will be working closely with Fiona during the coming year to give our insight towards initiative being driven down by the Canadian Construction Association (CCA). In addition to this initiative CSC also plans to work closer with VRCA for education as well. Education is part of the mission for CSC and working closely with VRCA we hope to tap into a larger market. CSC will be hosting an in-class PCD course (proposed start date January 27th, 2016). These courses are held at the VRCA classroom, check the website for registration information or email Robert Jahnsen at (Robert@div7.ca). In addition CSC National is hosting a Winter Workshop in Vancouver for Construction Contract Administration (CCA) March 7-11, 2016. This gives people the option of completing the course in 5 days. This course will be held at the Pacific Gateway Hotel in Richmond. If you or someone you know is interested in any of these courses or the variety of online courses offered, please let us know.

Download the entire issue for this article and more.
For more issues, visit our website or visit our archive for past issues.